Cellcom Israel posts profitable growth in Q2’09
www.WirelessFederation.com/news: Cellcom Israel Announces Second Quarter 2009 Results
- 15.0% Increase in Net Income With an Increase in Operating Income and EBITDA
- Profitability Growth, Despite the Ongoing Economic Slowdown, Price Erosions and Growing Competition
- EBITDA Up by 2.9%; EBITDA Margin of 39.6%
- Cellcom Israel Declares a Second Quarter Dividend of NIS 3.05 per Share (Totals Approx. NIS 300 Million)
- Total Revenues from services increased 0.7% to NIS 1,420 million ($362 million)
- Revenues from content and value added services (including SMS) increased 30.6%, represent 14.7% of services revenues
- Total Revenues totaled NIS 1,608 million ($410 million), a 0.5% increase
- EBITDA increased 2.9%(3) to NIS 637 million ($163 million) EBITDA margin 39.6%
- Operating income increased 6.5%(5) to NIS 444 million ($113 million)
- Net income increased 15.0% to NIS 277 million ($71 million)
- Free Cash Flow(2) increased 33.3% to NIS 400 million ($102 million)
- Subscriber base increased approx. 20,000 during the quarter, mostly post-paid subscribers; reaching approx. 3.228 million at the end of June 2009
- 3G subscribers reached approx. 877,000 at the end of June 2009, net addition of approx. 44,000 in the second quarter 2009
- The Company declared second quarter dividend of NIS 3.05 per share
Cellcom Israel Ltd. announced today its financial results for the second quarter of 2009. Revenues for the second quarter 2009 totaled NIS 1,608 million ($410 million); EBITDA for the second quarter 2009 totaled NIS 637 million ($163 million), or 39.6% of revenues; and net income for the second quarter 2009 reached NIS 277 million ($71 million). Basic earnings per share for the second quarter 2009 reached NIS 2.82 ($0.72).
Commenting on the results, Amos Shapira, Chief Executive Officer said, “This quarter Cellcom Israel, Israel’s largest and leading cellular operator, further strengthened its standing in the market, continuing to present growth in revenues, operating and net profit and cash flow, as well as steadily increasing and improving its subscriber base. These results are especially noteworthy as we are operating in a challenging competitive environment, highly regulated and turbulent macro-economic environment. This macro-economic environment mainly affected our roaming revenues, as inbound and outbound tourism continued to be impacted by the global economic slowdown. This effect of the decrease in roaming revenues was entirely offset by the rapidly growing demand for content and value added services, which increased by over 30% this quarter, as well as land line services in which we continue to present a significant growth almost without adding to the Company’s costs due to the existing synergy to our core business. Moreover, our ongoing efficiency measures this quarter enabled us to further reduce operating expenses, as well as operating expense as a percent of revenues, enabling us to present growth in both operating and net income and cash flow.
This quarter we continued to execute on our strategy of focusing on our core competencies, mobile communications, addressing the growing needs of the always on, anywhere consumer; the consumer that is constantly seeking entertainment and information content, known as Infotainment. We continued with our policy to offer our subscribers a variety of handsets to fulfill their changing needs, while keeping a prudent purchase policy. In this framework, we have launched, in a primary launch in Israel, the “Android” by Samsung with Google’s operating system and in the near future we will launch the iPhone by Apple. “.
Shapira added, commenting on the change in Chief Financial Officers: “I would like to take this opportunity to thank Tal Raz for his tremendous dedication and contribution to Cellcom Israel. Tal has been instrumental in bringing the Company to where it stands today, taking advantage of financial opportunities to restructure our debt in an optimal and most successful manner. Tal leaves us to take on the role of CEO of Clal Finance, another company in the IDB Group, and I wish him the best of success. I would like to also take the opportunity to welcome Yaacov Heen to the position of CFO. Yaacov, a highly experienced manager has grown through the Cellcom Israel ranks in the past 12 years, and is highly attuned and knowledgeable of the company. I wish Yaacov the best of success and believe you will have the opportunity to meet him in person in the near future.”
Tal Raz, Chief Financial Officer, commented: “These strong quarterly results were achieved mainly due to the increased revenues from content and value added services as well as fixed line revenues, which totally offset the 3.1% erosion in ARPU we witnessed this quarter, compared to last year, which resulted mainly from lower roaming revenues. Moreover, our very tight rein on expenses further contributed to profitability as marketing, sales, general and administrative expenses, as a percent of revenues, decreased from 21.9% in second quarter last year to 21.3% in second quarter this year. In terms of cash generation, we continued to generate a very healthy Free Cash Flow, increasing 33% from last year to NIS 400 million, enabling us to once again distribute a dividend totaling approximately NIS 300 million, representing 108% of net income, to our shareholders.”
Subscriber Acquisition and Retention Costs
Following the Company’s earnings release for the first quarter of 2009, dated May 26, 2009, relating to the accounting treatment for subscriber acquisition and retention costs, management has decided to change its accounting policy to recognize certain subsidies provided to handsets which are sold with a service agreement containing guaranteed minimum future revenue, as additional costs that are eligible for capitalization. Under the Company’s previous accounting policy, capitalized customer acquisition and retention costs included only deferred costs in respect of sales commissions related to the acquisition and retention of subscribers, provided the costs could be measured reliably and were directly attributable to obtaining a specific subscriber, and the Company recognized subsidies on handset sales as an expense in the period incurred. The change in policy has been retrospectively applied from January 1, 2007, and therefore, the comparable data for previous periods has been amended to reflect this change in accounting policy. The deferral and capitalization of such subsidies increased the Company’s retained earnings, as of January 1, 2009 by approximately NIS 48 million ($12 million). The impact of the change in accounting policy on the EBITDA for the second quarter of 2009 totaled approximately NIS 16 million ($4 million), similar to the impact on the EBITDA for the second quarter last year. The impact on the Company’s net income for the second quarter of 2009 totaled approximately NIS 4 million ($1 million), while net income for the second quarter last year did not change as a result of the change in the accounting policy.
Financial Review
Revenues for the second quarter of 2009 increased 0.5% totaling NIS 1,608 million ($410 million), compared to NIS 1,600 million ($408 million) in the second quarter last year. The increase in revenues is mainly attributed to a 0.7% increase in revenues from services, which reached NIS 1,420 million ($362 million) in the second quarter 2009 as compared to NIS 1,410 million ($360 million) in the second quarter last year. This increase was offset in part by a 1.1% decrease in handset and accessories’ revenues, from NIS 190 million ($48 million) in the second quarter last year, to NIS 188 million ($48 million) in the second quarter 2009.
The higher service revenues resulted mainly from a 30.6% increase in content and value added services (including SMS) revenues in the second quarter 2009, compared to the second quarter last year. Revenues from content and value added services reached NIS 209 million ($53 million), or 14.7% of service revenues. Furthermore, the increase in landline services revenues during the quarter also contributed to the higher service revenues. These increases were partially offset by the ongoing airtime price erosion as well as a substantial decrease in revenues from roaming services following the significant reduction in incoming and outgoing tourism resulting from the global economic slowdown.
Cost of revenues for the second quarter of 2009 totaled NIS 819 million ($209 million), similar to the second quarter last year. Cost of revenues reflects the deferral of handsets subsidies, as described above under -”Subscriber Acquisition and Retention Costs” – which amounted to NIS 16 million ($4 million) in the second quarter of 2009, as well as in the second quarter last year. The amortization of such deferred handsets subsidies totaled NIS 21 million ($5 million) in the second quarter 2009 compared to NIS 16 million ($4 million) in the second quarter 2008. Cost of revenues also reflects a decrease in royalties to the Ministry of Communications due to the reduced royalties’ rate in 2009, as well as lower depreciation expenses. These decreases were partially offset by an increase in cost of content and value-added services, due to increased usage, and in rent expenses, due to the one-time reversal of rent expenses in the amount of approximately NIS 14 million ($4 million) in the second quarter of 2008 following the clarification by the Israel Accounting Standards Board to the International Accounting Standard no. 39 (“Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement”).
Gross profit for the second quarter of 2009 increased 1% reaching NIS 789 million ($201 million), compared to NIS 781 million ($199 million) in the second quarter of 2008. Gross profit margin for the second quarter 2009 increased to 49.1% from 48.8% in the second quarter last year.
Selling, Marketing, General and Administrative Expenses (“SG&A Expenses”) for the second quarter of 2009 totaled NIS 343 million ($87 million), compared to NIS 350 million ($89 million) in the second quarter of 2008. The decrease in SG&A Expenses in the quarter is mainly due to a decrease in advertising expenses and in salaries and related expenses primarily resulted from a decrease in option related expenses. These decreases were partially offset by an increase in amortization of deferred sales commissions from NIS 8 million ($2 million) in second quarter last year to NIS 14 million ($4 million) in the second quarter this year, while deferred sales commissions slightly increased from approximately NIS 14 million ($4 million) in second quarter last year to approximately NIS 15 million ($4 million) in the second quarter this year. The decrease in SG&A Expenses was also offset in part by an increase in bad debts and doubtful accounts expenses, mainly following the number portability, which allows subscribers to switch between cellular operators prior to settling their outstanding debt. The increase in bad debts and doubtful accounts may also have been influenced by the global economic slowdown.
Operating income for the second quarter 2009 increased 6.5%, or 3.0% without elimination of the effect of the one-time reversal of rent expenses in the second quarter 2008 as mentioned above, reaching NIS 444 million ($113 million), compared to NIS 431 million ($110 million) in the second quarter last year.
EBITDA for the second quarter 2009 increased 2.9%, or 0.6% without elimination of the effect of the one-time reversal of rent expenses in the second quarter 2008 as mentioned above, reaching NIS 637 million ($163 million), compared to NIS 633 million ($162 million) in the second quarter of 2008. EBITDA as a percent of revenues, totaled 39.6% similar to the second quarter last year (without elimination of the above mentioned one-time effect).
Financing Expenses, net for the second quarter 2009 totaled NIS 67 million ($17 million), compared to NIS 109 million ($28 million) in the second quarter last year. The decrease resulted mainly from the 1.9% inflation in the second quarter this year, compared to 2.4% in the second quarter last year, which led to lower linkage expenses to the Israeli Consumer Price Index (CPI), associated with the Company’s debentures. The decrease also resulted from the one-time reversal, in the second quarter last year, of financing income in the amount of approximately NIS 29 million related to embedded derivatives. These decreases were offset in part by an increase in interest expenses related to the Company’s debentures, due to the increased debt level.
Net Income for the second quarter 2009 increased 15%, or 20.4% without elimination of the one-time effects in the second quarter 2008 as mentioned above, reaching NIS 277 million ($71 million), compared to NIS 230 million ($59 million) in the second quarter last year. Basic earnings per share for the second quarter 2009 totaled NIS 2.82 ($0.72), compared to NIS 2.35 ($0.60) in the second quarter 2008.
Operating Review
New Subscribers – at the end of June 2009 the Company had approximately 3.228 million subscribers. During the second quarter of 2009 the Company added approximately 20,000 net new subscribers, mostly post-paid.
In the second quarter of 2009, the Company added approximately 44,000 net new 3G subscribers to its 3G subscriber base, reaching approximately 877,000 3G subscribers at the end of June 2009, representing 27.2% of the Company’s total subscriber base, an increase from the 26% 3G subscribers represented of total subscribers at the end of March 2009.
The Churn Rate in the second quarter 2009 declined to 4.6%, compared to 4.7% in the second quarter last year and 5.0% in the first quarter this year. The churn for those quarters primarily consists of lower contribution pre-paid subscribers and subscribers with collection problems.
Average monthly subscriber Minutes of Use (“MOU”) in the second quarter 2009 totaled 330.4 minutes, compared to 331.8 minutes in the second quarter 2008, a decrease of 0.4%. Following the regulatory requirement to change the basic airtime charging units from twelve-second to one-second units commencing January 1, 2009, MOU for the second quarter 2008 has been adjusted to the same per-one second unit basis to enable a comparison. MOU for the second quarter of 2008 based on the former charging units was 354.3 minutes.
The monthly Average Revenue per User (ARPU) for the second quarter 2009 decreased 3.5% and totaled NIS 143.7 ($36.7), compared to NIS 148.9 ($38.0) in the second quarter last year. This decrease was, among others, the result of the lower roaming revenues recorded during the second quarter following the decline in tourism.
Financing and Investment Review
Cash Flow
Free cash flow (Cash provided by operating activities, net of cash used in investing activities) for the second quarter of 2009 increased 33.3%, reaching NIS 400 million ($102 million), compared to NIS 300 million ($77 million) generated in the second quarter of 2008. The increase in Free Cash Flow resulted mainly from an increase in net cash provided by operating activities totaled NIS 522 million ($133 million) in second quarter this year, compared to NIS 449 million ($115 million) in the second quarter last year.
Shareholders’ Equity
Shareholders’ Equity as of June 30, 2009 amounted to NIS 412 million ($105 million), primarily consisting of accumulated undistributed retained earnings.
Investment in Fixed Assets and Intangible Assets
During the second quarter 2009, the Company invested NIS 170 million ($43 million) in fixed assets and intangible assets (including, among others, deferred sales commissions and handsets subsidies and investments in information systems and software), compared to NIS 143 million ($36 million) in the second quarter 2008.
Dividend
On August 16, 2009, the Company’s board of directors declared a cash dividend in the amount of NIS 3.05 per share, and in the aggregate amount of approximately NIS 300 million (the equivalent of approximately $0.80 per share and approximately $79 million in the aggregate, based on the representative rate of exchange on August 14, 2009; The actual US$ amount for dividend paid in US$ will be converted from NIS based upon the representative rate of exchange published by the Bank of Israel on September 10, 2009), subject to withholding tax described below. The dividend will be payable to all of the Company’s shareholders of record at the end of the trading day in the NYSE on August 31, 2009. The payment date will be September 14, 2009. According to the Israeli tax law, the Company will deduct at source 20% of the dividend amount payable to each shareholder, as aforesaid, subject to applicable exemptions. The dividend per share that the Company will pay for the second quarter of 2009 does not reflect the level of dividends that will be paid for future quarterly periods, which can change at any time in accordance with the Company’s dividend policy. A dividend declaration is not guaranteed and is subject to the Company’s board of directors’ sole discretion, as detailed in the Company’s annual report for the year ended December 31, 2008 on Form 20-F, under “Item 8 – Financial Information – Dividend Policy”.
Other developments during the second quarter of 2009 and subsequent to balance sheet date
Site Licensing
As previously disclosed, following the Israeli Attorney General’s opinion that the exemption from obtaining building permits relied upon by cellular operators, including us, applies to cellular networks, a petition seeking to annul his opinion and apply a District Court ruling that the cellular operators devices do not meet the exemption’s requirements was filed with the Supreme Court in July 2008. Furthermore, an inter-ministry committee was established, as per the Attorney General’s opinion, to examine the appropriateness of future application of the exemption. In June 2009, another petition seeking similar remedies as the July 2008 petition, was filed with the Supreme Court, against the Attorney General, the Inter-ministry committee, the Minister of Interior, the Minister of Environmental Protection, the Minister of Communications, the Minister of Health and the cellular companies, including us. The petitioners also requested an interim order to prevent the construction of cell sites in reliance on the exemption. The petition and the request for interim order are awaiting determination by the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court decided to hear both petitions together in November 2009. In July 2009, subsequent to the balance sheet date, the inter-ministry committee published its recommendations for future application of the exemption. While the Ministry of Communication recommended that, given the difficulties in obtaining permits for the construction of cell sites, the exemption should be reviewed after the lapse of one to two years from the approval of the new National Zoning Plan 36, to verify that it provides an adequate solution that allows the cellular operators to provide required communication services, the Ministries of Interior and Environmental Protection recommended that the exemption be annulled within 6 months from the date of the recommendations, based ,among others, on the following claims: (1) current cellular infrastructure is sufficient, given it is currently used to provide advanced services such as internet, radio and television broadcasting, while such services may be provided by a landline network; and (2) sites constructed pursuant to a building permit are preferable to radio access devices regarding radiation safety and the provision of advanced services which can be provided through a landline network, over a cellular network, is unjustified in light of the preventive care principle set in the Israeli Non-Ionizing Radiation Law.
For additional details see the Company’s most recent annual report for the year ended December 31, 2008 on Form 20-F under “Item 3. Key Information – D. Risk Factors – Risks related to our business – We may not be able to obtain permits to construct cell sites” as well as under “Item 4. Information on the Company – B. Business Overview – Government Regulations – Permits for Cell site Construction – Site Licensing” and “Construction and operating permits from the commissioner of environmental radiation”.
MVNO
The Israeli Communication Law was amended in July 2009, subsequent to the balance sheet date, to include a Mobile Virtual Network Operator, or MVNO, license. Under the amendment, the Ministry of Communications is required to enact the regulations necessary for the provision of the MVNO license by September 1, 2009. The amendment further instructs that in the event that a MVNO and the cellular operator will not have reached an agreement as to the provision of service by way of MVNO within six months from the date the MVNO has approached the cellular operator, and if the Ministry of Communications together with the Ministry of Commerce determine that the failure to reach an agreement is due to unreasonable conditions imposed by the cellular operator, the Ministry Of Communications will use its authority to provide instructions. Such instructions may include intervening in the terms of the agreement, including by setting the price of the service.
For additional details see the Company’s most recent annual report for the year ended December 31, 2008 on Form 20-F under “Item 3. Key Information – D. Risk Factors – Risks related to our business – We face intense competition in all aspects of our business” as well as under “Item 4. Information on the Company – B. Business Overview – Competition” and “Government Regulations – Mobile Virtual Network Operators”.
Handset Procurement
The Company has entered an agreement with Apple Sales International, for the purchase and distribution of iPhone handsets in Israel. Under the terms of the agreement, the Company has committed to purchase a minimum quantity of handsets during a period of three years, which is expected to represent a significant portion of the Company’s expected handset purchase amount over that period. The total amount of the purchases will depend on the handsets purchase price at the time of purchase.
MIRS
In August 2009, subsequent to the balance sheet date, the Company submitted a preliminary non-binding indication of interest to purchase 100% of the equity of MIRS Communications Ltd, another Israeli cellular provider with an estimated market share of 4-5%. For additional details regarding MIRS see our most recent Annual Report on Form 20-F for the year 2008 under “B. Business Overview – The Telecommunications Industry in Israel – Cellular Services”.
At this stage there is no certainty a transaction will be agreed upon nor executed. Any such transaction would be subject, among others, to certain regulatory approvals and there is no certainty that such approvals will be given.
Change of Chief Financial Officer
In July 2009, Mr. Tal Raz notified the Company of his resignation from office as the Company’s CFO, effective September 20, 2009, following his nomination as CEO of Clal Finance, an IDB group affiliate of the Company. The Company’s board of directors has nominated Mr. Yaacov Heen as the Company’s CFO, effective September 21, 2009, and resolved to recommend to the General Meeting of Shareholders to nominate Tal Raz as a director of the Company. For additional details see the Company’s immediate report (on Form 6-K) dated July 20, 2009 and the Company’s Proxy Statement (on Form 6-K) dated July 21,2009.
About Cellcom Israel
Cellcom Israel Ltd., established in 1994, is the leading Israeli cellular provider; Cellcom Israel provides its approximately 3.228 million subscribers (as at June 30, 2009) with a broad range of value added services including cellular and landline telephony, roaming services for tourists in Israel and for its subscribers abroad and additional services in the areas of music, video, mobile office etc., based on Cellcom Israel’s technologically advanced infrastructure. The Company operates an HSPA 3.5 Generation network enabling advanced high speed broadband multimedia services, in addition to GSM/GPRS/EDGE and TDMA networks. Cellcom Israel offers Israel’s broadest and largest customer service infrastructure including telephone customer service centers, retail stores, and service and sale centers, distributed nationwide. Through its broad customer service network Cellcom Israel offers its customers technical support, account information, direct to the door parcel services, internet and fax services, dedicated centers for the hearing impaired, etc. As of 2006, Cellcom Israel, through its wholly owned subsidiary Cellcom Fixed Line Communications L.P., provides landline telephone communication services in Israel, in addition to data communication services. Cellcom Israel’s shares are traded both on the New York Stock Exchange (CEL) and the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange (CEL). For additional information please visit the Company’s website www.cellcom.co.il
